Friday, 27 August 2010
France's ban on the veil has nothing to do with women's emancipation
"If there were any doubt about the motivation for the ban on Islamic face coverings passed by the French national assembly in July, the Sarkozy government's actions in August have laid them to rest.
The issue isn't women's emancipation, for all the pious rhetoric we've heard about equality being a "primordial value" of the French nation. It isn't the danger that terrorists and robbers will hide behind burqas in order to blow up buildings or rob banks – the exemptions in the law for motorcycle helmets, fencing and ski masks, and carnival costumes quickly dispel that argument. And it isn't about enforcing openness and transparency as an aspect of French culture.
Outlawing what the French call "le voile intégral" is part of a campaign to purify and protect national identity, purging so-called foreign elements – although many of these "foreigners" are actually French citizens – from membership in the nation. It is part of a cynical bid by Sarkozy and his party to capture the anti-immigrant, anti-Muslim animus that has brought electoral gains to the rightwing National Front party and to disarm the Socialist opposition, which has so far offered little resistance to the xenophobic campaign."
Thanks to the invaluable Islamophobia Watch website for highlighting this excellent article from Joan Wallach Scott, author of The Politics of the Veil.
The issue isn't women's emancipation, for all the pious rhetoric we've heard about equality being a "primordial value" of the French nation. It isn't the danger that terrorists and robbers will hide behind burqas in order to blow up buildings or rob banks – the exemptions in the law for motorcycle helmets, fencing and ski masks, and carnival costumes quickly dispel that argument. And it isn't about enforcing openness and transparency as an aspect of French culture.
Outlawing what the French call "le voile intégral" is part of a campaign to purify and protect national identity, purging so-called foreign elements – although many of these "foreigners" are actually French citizens – from membership in the nation. It is part of a cynical bid by Sarkozy and his party to capture the anti-immigrant, anti-Muslim animus that has brought electoral gains to the rightwing National Front party and to disarm the Socialist opposition, which has so far offered little resistance to the xenophobic campaign."
Thanks to the invaluable Islamophobia Watch website for highlighting this excellent article from Joan Wallach Scott, author of The Politics of the Veil.
Blog Archive
-
►
2011
(172)
-
►
June
(31)
- Public sector workers are fighting for us all
- Protest today at arrest of leading Palestinian act...
- Mental health care in crisis
- Alice Walker to join aid convoy to Gaza
- 100% British
- Billy Hayes on the cuts and multiculturalism
- Advice Surgery
- I will be interviewing Billy Hayes later...
- 100 women take part in Slutwalk
- Why we are losing the war in Afghanistan
- Brian Haw RIP
- Solidarity with Saudi women car drivers
- Support the Slutwalk
- A Sunday bike ride
- ‘People are getting more and more afraid of each o...
- Dutch Muslims and Jews unite to oppose ban on reli...
- Prevent and Neo-Conservative Ideology
- The Equality Act is not just 'red tape'
- 'Muslims call for action against hate crimes'
- Homophobia in Tower Hamlets: how a small group of ...
- Responses to Prevent
- Why do people believe in conspiracy theories?
- 'Birmingham universities rubbish claims of "compla...
- Cameron and Blair: the real counter-terrorism coal...
- The rise of far right parties in Europe
- Support the Connexions service
- Commemorating the Nakba
- Tonight at the movies: Chronicle of Protest
- Newsnight interview Arundhati Roy
- University campuses are not 'hotbeds of radicalisa...
- Sparkbrook's secret admirer
-
►
May
(26)
- Announcement of new Gaza aid flotilla marks annive...
- Germany to go nuclear free
- Remembering Gil
- 'There is nothing wrong with standing up for what ...
- Rafah crossing reopens today
- 'Obama, hands off our spring'
- 'Judge waits for medical report on racist who thre...
- Libyan war costs £38 million per week
- Justice for Stephen Lawrence
- "Does the BBC have a problem with Muslims?"
- The Future of British Islam
- I'm on The Big Questions, BBC 1 at 10am today
- Support the petition to halve household rubbish in...
- 'Ugandan parliament drops bill that would jail gay...
- 12 hours to stop Uganda's anti-gay bill
- ‘Controversial Birmingham surveillance cameras are...
-
►
June
(31)
-
▼
2010
(389)
-
▼
August
(28)
- 'Police chiefs misled Birmingham city council over...
- BNP in crisis
- France's ban on the veil has nothing to do with wo...
- 'All in this together'
- Drop aid, not bombs
- Empty words?
- Birmingham hit hardest by housing benefits cuts
- 'US troops to leave Iraq'. Not quite...
- EDL Bradford ban
- Thatcherism with piety
- A con artist at work
- Today's Advice Bureaux
- Save our Connexions service
- First the good news
- Pakistan floods fundraising event
- Desi Download - The Pakistan Floods
- Soccer Mums
- Ramadan Kareem
- Talking to the enemy
- Countering the cuts myths
- Can you pass the terrorism quiz?
- We should listen to Tony's call
- Vacuous feminism
- 'Take them down!'
- Get the story right!
- A milllion voices for a million homes
- Support the Pakistan floods crisis appeal
- 'Nick Clegg's shameful U-turn on cuts'
-
▼
August
(28)
Web Links
- Salma Yaqoob on Twitter
- Salma Yaqoob on YouTube
- Salma Yaqoob on Facebook
- Salma Yaqoob on Flickr
- Salma Yaqoob on MySpace
- Birmingham Respect
- The Respect Party
- George Galloway MP
- Abjol Miah
- Dr Kay Phillips
- Stop the War Coalition
- Philosophy Football
- Socialist Unity Blog
- Trade Union Congress
- Naomi Klein
- Viva Palestina
- Democracy Now
- Anti War.com
